Saturday, March 29, 2014

End Review: 1984



            One of the lessons that 1984 drives home really well is the idea that perspective is, in some sense, everything.  As the reader, I predicted that this “negative utopia” would “end in a blunt, horrific way.”  For me, this was the case, because (spoiler) Smith finally succumbed to the Party and convinced himself to give what was left of his heart to the regime.  “He loved Big Brother” (245) (end spoiler).  Throughout the entire book, I tagged along as Smith fought against the totalitarian powers that so desperately wanted to squeeze the life out of him.  To see him give in with such helplessness was disappointing, to say the least.
            On the other hand, Smith had been changed so much that for him, to love Big Brother seemed like an instinct.  I think this is one of, if not the, primary points that Orwell wants to drive home.  When an individual or group wields so much control that the subjects they govern are no longer themselves, all hope is lost.  When we are stripped of rhyme and reason, we become automatons.  As a thinking, somewhat rational human being, the thought of no longer being in control of my own mind is frightening.
            Luckily, we are not, at least in America, at that point.  There is a difference between privacy and sanity.  Privacy induces the notion that there must be something other than existence in the public eye, while sanity suggests control over one’s thoughts, feelings, and actions.  When people exploded over the news about the NSA, they were concerned about privacy, and yet they seemed (at least to me) to be reacting to the issue of sanity.  As far as I know, all the NSA was doing was collecting bulk amounts of data.  Unless an individual raised suspicion, no single person was tagged.  However, people felt like their lives were being intruded upon, that every move they made, every sound they uttered, was being scrutinized.  Again, as far as I know, that’s just not true.  After reading 1984, I certainly don’t think data collection should go any further in the sense that all individuals suddenly are watched and monitored.  In cases where individuals were targeted for strategic -- not security -- purposes, that needs to stop, but as long as we can think freely and critically (in other words, as sane humans) people should stop criticizing the NSA.
            Back to the subject of 1984.  One of the ideas that really stuck with me was the notion “that if you want to keep a secret you must also hide it from yourself” (231).  In a world where individuals really are scrutinized, locking any revealing information away from even yourself appears to be one of the most valuable survival tools.  I simply cannot imagine having to lockdown my own mind.
            I have never read a dystopian novel in its entirety, and after finishing 1984, I must say they are quite fascinating.  While they tell of bleak futures, they also offer insight into the present, when there is still hope.  I would strongly recommend this book to anyone who cares about mankind.  Check back for insights and commentary on the next book I’ll be reading (Outliers, by Malcolm Gladwell)!

Thursday, March 27, 2014

Midway Review: 1984



            In my first post about 1984, I shared the following comment, written on the back of the book about both this story and Brave New World; they are “not dramas of what life might be…but nightmares of what it is becoming.”  As I’ve been reading this book, I’ve become so engrossed in the story that sometimes I forget the context in which it was written.  The year 1984 already happened.  Thirty years ago.  The “future” in this story is the past for me.  Even though this is the case, it isn’t cause for celebration, because there are still lessons to be learned from Orwell’s skillfully written book.
            Although I knew the general premise of the novel, I didn’t picture that it would have such an (at times) introverted perspective.  The reader gets to take a good look into the mind of Winston Smith, the primary protagonist.  He ponders some hefty questions, like what it means to think, and why the past is so crucial for the present and the future.  There are many conflicts that arise throughout the plot, and Smith offers an interesting angle.  He remarks “that in moments of crisis one is never fighting against an external enemy but always against one’s own body” (86).  In a world so filled with eavesdropping, dictatorial, unyielding authorities, to place the burden of getting through a tough situation on oneself is remarkable, to say the least.
            I think this is where a lot of people nowadays fall short.  We are so quick to place the blame on others that we forget to question our own actions.  America erupted when revelations about the NSA’s bulk collection of data were leaked, but it seems like a lot of people forgot to put the government’s actions into context.  It is the government’s duty to protect us, and if we feel so strongly about privacy, why is it that scores of people still continue to post revealing pictures and raucous messages for the world to see?
            If anything, 1984 has taught me so far to not only be aware of what’s around you, but also to be aware of what’s in you.  The Party maintains control by seeping not only into the homes of citizens, but also into their minds.  I pride myself in being able to think freely, and while it’s not quite “1984” in America right now, it is in other parts of the world.  People who cannot exercise a fundamental right to think freely must surely question the force oppressing them, but if they have nothing with which to compare their lives, do they in fact challenge their predicament?  For me, this is where a major piece of the book comes in.  “Doublethink means the power of holding two contradictory beliefs in one’s mind simultaneously, and accepting both of them” (176).  Around the world, people live in unfortunate situations, and may often want to deny what’s happening to them, but if that is their reality, they may also have to accept and deal with it.
            The story is fictional, but it is written with such impeccable attention to detail that at times I find myself believing (to my dismay) that our world may one day become in some way or another like that in 1984.  And the story is, after all, about this world, so while characters and conflicts are made up, geopolitical, philosophical, and economic references make the novel seem less like a story and more like a firsthand account of reality.
            Although 1984 was written a while ago, it still contains valuable concepts.  Usually books that are filled with morals end on a slightly upbeat note (at least based on my experience as a reader).  However, this book seems to be drained of any hope, and I imagine it will end in a blunt, horrific way.  Despite a potentially dark ending, I am still looking forward to finishing this book.  Check back for my final analysis on 1984!

Sunday, March 23, 2014

Introduction: 1984



            In the wake of all of the revelations about the NSA’s secret programs to collect bulk amounts of data and tap into people’s lives, I think now is a perfect time to read 1984, written by George Orwell (the pen name of Eric Blair).  Now, before you jump to any conclusions about my interpretation of and feeling towards all of the information about the NSA, let me first say that one of the primary reasons I’m reading this novel is to give me some perspective.
            I think at times bulk collection of data isn’t an issue.  If the individuals working in the government are not able to identify individuals whose information they have collected, then no harm is done.  And if people are identified, it’s probably because they pose some sort of threat, in which case thwarting plots makes the world better.  However, the targeting of individuals (say, in other governments) is completely irresponsible and dishonest.  Trust, in my opinion, is stronger than treaties and pacts, and violating a person’s goodwill and loyalty is not the way to do business and establish/cultivate strong relationships.
            Maybe, however, there are some things the general public shouldn’t know about.  In order to be safe and secure, maybe the people we elect to protect our interests do have the right to collect information on us.  I don’t know.  It’s a really complicated issue, and hopefully reading this book will help me to make more informed decisions and come to more educated conclusions about privacy and government programs.
            This book certainly focuses on one aspect of government control.  On the back of the book, 1984 (and Brave New World) are described as being “not dramas of what life might be…but nightmares of what it is becoming.”  In the description about Orwell, it is stated that “He hated totalitarianism.”  He also left “behind a substantial body of work, a growing reputation for greatness, and the conviction that modern man was inadequate to cope with the demands of his history.”  Reading this book will either reinforce arguments I have already heard, or make me think differently about what is going on now, when we still have some ability to change the course of history.